Fresh Seafood

Fresh Catch Seafood



Serving The Freshest Locally Caught Seafood from our Long Island Waters

The Fresh Catch Seafood Difference

Play Video about Fresh Seafood

Our Seafood is caught locally, right here on Long Island by Local Fisherman.

When you go to your supermarkets and buy Seafood, it’s often farm-raised in terrible conditions. Then it’s packaged for shipment on ice. Displayed in their cases and then re-frozen and injected with dyes to make the fish look good and last longer. This is a daily routine for these places.

Here in St. James, NY at Fresh Catch Seafood, our Seafood is locally caught from our waters and goes from the boats to your table the same day. No artificial coloring, no ice and re-ice methods here. Just the freshest, highest quality, local Seafood is served to our community.

Get Hooked on Fresh Catch Seafood!

Come visit us at 95 Lake Ave, St. James NY 11780 (Get Directions)

Our Customer Reviews

  • 5 star review  Freshest fish on all of Long Island! I have never seen cod as white and beautiful anywhere else except for this place! You must come here if you want the... read more

    thumb Unknown
    October 7, 2021
  • 5 star review  I can't say enough about Ryan and his staff they are all so helpful, courteous and knowledgeable. If you're like me a little afraid of not knowing how to... read more

    thumb Mary Caramico
    September 21, 2021
  • 5 star review  Great place fresh seafood

    thumb Pamela Hurley
    September 21, 2021
  • 5 star review  Everything we picked up from there was amazing...the best we have had! Lobster, steamers, monk fish and their cooked jumbo shrimp!!!! Cannot wait to go again! You will not be... read more

    thumb Dori Ann Casillo
    September 21, 2021
  • 5 star review  Ordered white clam sauce for this weekend, it was amazing and fresh! Everyone loved it. Anything we’ve ever gotten from Ryan has been fresh and delicious, lobsters, steamers, mussels, scallops,... read more

    thumb Barbara Bart
    September 21, 2021
  • 5 star review  Fresh Catch is the best. Everything is so fresh. I have been going all summer long. I highly recommend it. Ryan and his staff are so nice and knowledgeable. They... read more

    thumb Jane M
    September 21, 2021
  • 5 star review  I purchased amazing shrimp for shrimp scampi they were so friendly and gave tips for extra flavor. Will do all my seafood shopping here and have highly recommended to all... read more

    thumb Karen Biscotti
    September 21, 2021
  • 5 star review  Friendly service, great blue crabs, will come back and recommend to my friends!!

    thumb John Spiegel
    August 21, 2021
  • 5 star review  My daughter found this place when she was visiting us for a week from Manhattan. She wanted to make dinner for us. The soft shell crabs were beautiful!!!, and fresh... read more

    thumb maria ambrosio
    July 31, 2021
  • 5 star review  Freshest and best seafood around...They tell you what type of fish and where it came many local options to choose form as well, best prices for what you are... read more

    thumb Diana Bruni
    June 30, 2021

Write Your Review on Google

We Are Open:

Monday – Closed

Tuesday – Closed

Wednesday – 12-6PM

Thursday – 12-6PM

Friday – 12-6PM

Saturday – 10:30AM-6PM

Sunday – 10:30AM-5PM 

Follow us on Social Media!

Fresh Catch Seafood, LLC.

95 Lake Ave, St, James NY, 11780

Fresh Catch Seafood LLC. All Rights Reserved 2021 © ™

95 Lake Ave. St. James, NY 11780 – Call (631) 335-6439