Fresh Seafood Menu
* Prices are subject to change without notice. Please call Fresh Catch Seafood ahead to find out pricing and quantities on hand.
Fresh Fish
- Fresh Montauk sword steaks $22/lb
Fresh Montauk sword steaks, Price per pound.
- Fresh Montauk Yellow-Fin Tuna $25/lb
Fresh Montauk NY yellow-fin tuna. Priced per pound.
- Fresh Montauk summer flounder (fluke) fillet $22/lb
Fresh Montauk summer flounder (fluke) fillet
- Fresh local Montauk Sea Bass fillet $22/lb
Fresh local Montauk Sea Bass fillet.
- Chilean Sea Bass Fillet $25/lb
Chilean Sea Bass Fillet
- Fresh Montauk Cod Loins $20/lb
Fresh Montauk Cod Loins.
- Fresh eastern Atlantic Halibut fillet $25/lb
Fresh eastern Atlantic Halibut fillet)
- Fresh Caribbean Red Snapper fillet $25/lb
Fresh Caribbean Red Snapper fillet
- Fresh Florida Black Grouper fillet $25/lb
Fresh Florida Black Grouper fillet. Price per pound.
- Fresh Montauk Monk fish tails $17/lb
Fresh Montauk Monk fish tails. Per Pound.
- Fresh Canadian fatty delicious Salmon fillet $20/lb
Fresh Canadian fatty delicious Salmon fillet. Price per pound.
- Golden Tile Fish Fillet $23/lb
Golden Tile Fish Fillet. Per Pound.
- Montauk Hake Fillet $20/lb
Montauk Hake Fillet (Better than Cod) per pound.
- Blackfish Fillet $23/lb
Fresh Blackfish Fillet. Priced per pound.
- Fresh Red Snapper $23/lb
Fresh Red Snapper Priced per pound.
Shell Fish
- Fresh Long Island sound steamers $12/lb
Fresh long island sound steamers
- Fresh Stony Brook little neck Clams $7/doz
Fresh stony brook harbor little necks
- Fresh Long Island Sound Oysters $18/doz
Fresh diver caught Long Island sound oysters
- Fresh (pei) mussels clean (2 lbs) $10
- Fresh Long Island Atlantic Sea Scallops (dry) $25/lb
Fresh Long Island Atlantic Sea Scallops (dry). Per Pound.
- Wild colossal Cocktail Shrimp $25/lb
Wild colossal Cocktail Shrimp. Priced per pound.
- Wild colossal raw U-10 Shrimp $22/lb
Wild colossal raw U-10 Shrimp
- Wild 21/25 White Gulf Shrimp $18/lb
Wild 21/25 White Gulf Shrimp. Priced per pound.
- Fresh Octopus $15/lb
Fresh Octopus Price per pound.
- Fresh Squid/Calamari $15/lb
Fresh Squid/Calamari. Price per pound.
- Fresh Lobsters (whole) $ Call
Prices vary. Please call us ahead to find out the daily price.
- Fresh Lobster Tails $ Call
Prices vary. Please call us ahead to find out the daily price.
- Fresh Blue Claw Crabs (Soft Shell) $ Call
Fresh Blue Claw Crabs (Soft Shell)
- Fresh Blue Claw Crabs (Hard Shell) $22/doz
Fresh Blue Claw Crabs (Hard Shell)
Sides / Sauces
- Fresh Seaweed Salad $4/lb
Fresh Made Seaweed salad.
- Fresh catch cocktail sauce $4/ea
Homemade Fresh catch cocktail sauce
- White clam sauce fresh made $22/qt
White clam sauce fresh made! Perfect for Linguine and Clam Sauce!
- Delicious Homemade Baked Clams $2/ea.
Delicious Homemade Baked Clams. Priced per each clam.
Disclaimer: We strongly encourage all of our patrons to fully wash and cook all of their fish and shellfish prior to consumption. Please visit this link Here to learn more.
We Are Open:
Monday – Closed
Tuesday – Closed
Wednesday – 12-6PM
Thursday – 12-6PM
Friday – 12-6PM
Saturday – 10:30AM-6PM
Sunday – 10:30AM-5PM
Fresh Catch Seafood, LLC.
95 Lake Ave, St, James NY, 11780
95 Lake Ave. St. James, NY 11780 – Call (631) 335-6439